Aylon cast
GBConflict in Construct Hello, my name is Alan. I purchased this book from the Mar Vista Time Travel. I think the premise of this movement is terrific. However, as I was reading this story to my daughter, I got to Artmesia Gentileschi and felt uncomfortable. At page 20 the passage reads, Agostino wanted his star pupil to also be his lover. "I promise I will marry you", he told her. Artmesia kept saying no. I did not quite understand it, so my partner and I spoke about it and looked a little more in depth into that background and it did not take long to come to the fact that Artmesia was Raped; and the situation was not coined the term only because she was underage, she was full fledge taken advantage of. Now, the story is obviously more intricate than that: Agostino promised to marry her and recanted his promise, women were not seen as people, rather descedants of men, and a caretaker is also to blame, apart from the father's blame. But the amount of detail needed in order to put its true story together, is important; unfortunately, it is not justifiable or fair for the writer to diminish what really happened, as a Woman, and for a Woman's sake (because these things really happen). Moreover, if that background is not neccessary, too dark, or even has too many complexities, it is probably best not mention it at all. Because it is a childrens book, I understand the necessity to keep it child-oriented, but I believe it is also best to be conscientious of every circumstance. All consecutively, I suggest it would be best not to veneer Artmesia's story -- And hopefully, not Anyone else's story in these books -- or just keep the dark backgrounds out, completely. Thank you for taking the time to read this. I appreciate the thought and reason for these books to exist. Keep getting better, thank you Sincerely Alan
Sarah Brown-Shields
CAREBEL GIRLS ROCK!! Absolutely love these books!! Started purchasing them for my daughter when the first volume was released. She has never liked picking up a book twice until these were added to our home library. She an I both love when the novels were released and have our fingers crossed more will be coming out in the future!!
Tracy
GBDisappointed about repeat stories I have loved this collection if books for my daughter. When I saw you had a new book, Rebel Girls Lead, I immediately bought it. She was so disappointed as most of the stories are repeats. I saw familiar faces on the cover, but assumed the stories would be different. It almost seems like the book was just rushed out to get Kamala Harris in a book. Thankfully, it was a cheap book as I am just as disappointed as my daughter.
Amie Thomasson
GBMy 8 year old daughter is obsessed with… My 8 year old daughter is obsessed with her Rebel Girls books. She says "I have never been so interested in non-fiction before! Really great stories. I especially like the ones that have parts about the people when they were kids." She is learning so much, not only about inspriring women, but also about geography and history from these books. .
Daniel Ernenwein
GBMy students have absolutely loved these… My students have absolutely loved these books. I love the chapter books! They are really interesting stories that make it more fun to learn about the powerful women. I teach 3rd grade and they can read and understand the books really well. Thank you for creating these amazing stories. It really helps me diversify my library and empower my young students.