Unlikely to renew my membership Been a member for years, 5 or so, and over that time I have seen some good returns. However, more and more now we receive US listed recommendations, instead of UK. I signed up for motley fool UK not USA. Unfortunately the performance of picks vs the market has decreased to being almost equal. Unlikely to renew membership.

Very happy Share Advisor subscriber Have subscribed to Share Advisor for almost ten years now and while I no longer buy individual shares, those I have bought on the back of Foolish recommendations have done well in the main. It pays to be a patient investor for Share Advisor subscribers, as the SA team have a long term, value oriented outlook. The research is in-depth and the guidance considered. I don't have a massive portfolio but my monthly dividend income more than covers the annual fee, plus I've been getting double digit growth most years.

I'm surprised at the number of negative… I'm surprised at the number of negative reviews. I can only conclude that some expect too much. Motley Fool do their research and come to reasonable conclusions. But they don't have a crystal ball. Investors have a responsibility, I think, to be careful and not simply invest in a recommendation they haven't looked into themselves. Consider Motley Fool as a starting point, not a rubber stamp. Most of the recommendations I leave alone. Those I have picked have for the most part done well, far better than the annual fee.

Reasonable service - must try harder Too much spam, which distracts from the paid for service. Sometimes intermittent coverage and reviews. Some “Best Buy now” recommended shares falling by very large double digits losses in the following week. Cross selling other services makes you wonder why you’re paying for the one you have.

I used to subscribe 20 years ago and… I used to subscribe 20 years ago and have recently rejoined. There are 2 areas which I am unhappy with:- 1. I am only interested in UK stocks. Probably unwise but the vast majority of stock picks fall on deaf ears. I would happily subscribe to UK edition only. 2. Too much advertising of your products, too much spiel about providing info I would prefer something along the lines of: This month's recommendation is ABC Sector Recent Price P/E Dividend Concise comments I am seriously thinking of cancelling my subscription.