Mostly great. Will still order from them. The majority of the pins I ordered were wonderful. One of them (2014 LE PAX West) had a notable degree of the nickel plating on the top scraped/dinged off, which is a bit disappointing in a single, $60 pin.

Lots of Variety and Fast Shipping Honestly, I am very satisfied. There is a lot of variety for PAX pin collectors and it took less than a week for me to receive my pins. Some pins don't come with the original package so if that matters to you, just keep that in mind.

Reliable Reliable. Found out I missed a few pins from pax unplugged and paid the extra premium cost to get the pins I wanted, but they had fast shipping

Second Time Ordering, Satisfied Yet Again. Pins arrived quite quickly, and in good condition as well. Only slight issue is that I stopped getting shipping updates after around the first week of my order being shipped. But it still arrived, so I'm happy.

Good Service I've bought from pinny shop before and just bought from them again, ships fast and you always get what you paid for. My most recent order was a set of staff pins that were on sale for a decent price and two other pins, both 6$ but one was on sale for 5$, I grabbed both to put my order over the free shipping threshold and because I wanted them. For whatever reason later that day I check the website again and see one of the two extra pins, but the price is now just 5$, no sale, I check the other one because I'm a bit confused and it's also 5$, they dropped the price down right after I purchased my order. I lost a whole dollar but it left a weird enough taste in my mouth to bother writing this. Edited: Got my dollar refunded, probably should have just contacted customer support in the first place but I will leave the review up for clarity and to say I appreciate the fast customer service.