I received a non-renewal notice from… I received a non-renewal notice from this company after 10 years as a customer for no upgrades to my house in 20 years...except they seem to forget that THEY paid for a new roof after a hurricane in 2017!! Then after being with them for 10 years, to "take me back" they required I pay for a 4 point inspection. After I jumped through this hoop they told me to "take me back" I needed to replace my HVAC system, which works perfectly fine and gives me $70 electric bills!!!!! Like everyone has $3000 laying around to replace a perfectly good air conditioning system. Also it should be known I am a cancer patient in a pandemic!!! Thanks for being heartless, uncaring and unintelligent American Integrity!!! STAY AWAY FROM THIS COMPANY!!!

Lack of Communication for Services This insurance company is the worst service. I contacted them to get an auto insurance quote and was told to complete online, after I did that, I have never gotten a call back and heard back just to get a quote, and that was 4 or 5 months ago. Recently, I got an email to schedule an appointment to review my home insurance policy, which was scheduled today with an agent and NEVER got a call. These are just the simple things and they cannot follow through. I can only imagine if you have to file claim for something and there is no communication. This company should be a shame. It makes sense after reading all the reviews.

Kitchen damaged I had American Integrity for so many years, never had a claim before in June of 2017 I have dishwasher and under the sink likings big time the cabinets were the dishwasher machine and the sink get damaged all wood is mushy,rotten, have mold and the insurance think with $ 3.000 everything is gonna be fix. I m handicap person , I been call the insurance and nobody call me back. This company is a joke the Insurance Commissioner need pay attention to this can of company. My name C C Wood

Over 30 days after Hurricane Irma, still waiting for help....Update Update....I was contacted and received a settlement payment. My only complaint is the depreciation amount deducted from the payment to repair my home. Very disappointed with American Integrity Insurance Group. Hurricane Irma damaged my roof and my home over one month ago. The day after Irma hit I filed a claim. Over one month later, I am still waiting to get help for coverage that I paid for. Numerous calls and emails go without response. Neighbors with other homeowners insurance already having their claims settled and roofs repaired. Totally unacceptable!

No way to run an insurance company. Have had my homeowner's insurance with American Integrity since Dec 2012. Paid out of pocket 3 times over the first 7 years for 3 roof storm repairs ($5800) while annual premiums increased from $800 to $1900 over ten years. Roof received extensive damage during Irma, filed a claim which was denied. Had to retain a lawyer to recover $28K in damages - American Integrity finally had to settle for $58K -more than double what they would have paid if they just approved the initial claim. Little wonder they're having financial problems. Will renew with a different carrier with more 'integrity'.