Poor communication. Claim was completed timely, finalized and check sent before I could rebut their decision. I am fighting this decision and now I will not cash check as this would mean acceptance. AI is very hard to deal with and I know this is how some insurance companies operate. Wish it wasn't AI. After my second attempt to settle claim satisfactorily I will try another review.

A hailstorm hit our neighborhood in… A hailstorm hit our neighborhood in Leesburg, FL on March 27, 2019. I filed a claim, and they sent out a person from an engineering firm. Subsequently, American Integrity denied our claim by phone call from a secretary of the adjuster, who exclaimed that we had a "really good 30 year roof!" She was evidently reading from a script, or so it sounded. In the meantime, almost every home around us, in the dozens, are getting new roofs, except those insured by AI, and possibly one other company. I have signed with a roofing company to fight the claim for us.

Stay Away from American Integrity!!!!!! After several years paying on time and never submitting a claim, they sent me a Non renewal notice. Coincidence is, I recently opened a roof claim for wind damage and now they sent the non renewal notice. Reason for non renewal is roof age. Really American Integrity, this is how you treat your clients. I also had to involve a public claims adjuster because they clearly aren't wanting to pay up for the claim. This is ridiculous, I honestly hate companies that take advantage of honest people.

Had a claim after Ian Had a claim after Ian. Damages before deductible were approximately 25,000. Adjuster came out and wrote estimate below the 7k deductible. Called back and another adjuster came out. This time most of the items (5) were recognized as hurricane damage. Then the claim rep was changed. Almost two years later, I have had at least 3 writers and 4 agents. Still waiting for the payment of two remaining items. I was told the check was in the mail a month ago. Called to speak to a supervisor and was told a return call to me would be made within 24-48 hours. Still waiting?????? Terrible customer service. They renegotiate coverage after contract and payment is made. Whats up with that???

No way to run an insurance company. Have had my homeowner's insurance with American Integrity since Dec 2012. Paid out of pocket 3 times over the first 7 years for 3 roof storm repairs ($5800) while annual premiums increased from $800 to $1900 over ten years. Roof received extensive damage during Irma, filed a claim which was denied. Had to retain a lawyer to recover $28K in damages - American Integrity finally had to settle for $58K -more than double what they would have paid if they just approved the initial claim. Little wonder they're having financial problems. Will renew with a different carrier with more 'integrity'.