First time recent bulk buy (total of 4… First time recent bulk buy (total of 4 decks) to test the waters. Opened 2 different decks one was perfect and all cards were perfect. Second deck, considered the “premium playing cards” had me excited to open and play with until I saw one of the jokers had a fully bent corner. Was sadden and felt incomplete. I contacted customer service/support assuming that things wouldn’t be resolved and it was just ONE card which was just the joker card. But the customer service/support blew me away and I even refused the compensation from them but they’re persistent and their main goal is to keep customers. Never experienced this lvl of service, from communication and hassle free! Now I’m extremely confident on purchasing cards and will be coming back for me! Thanks Christen for your help and services!

Customer-Service Level: Legendary Hey—sometimes problems happen. It’s a fact of life. But when they do (side note: in the 4 years since I started ordering from Theory11—and that’s $1000+ in business I’ve given them—I’ve had ONE item arrive damaged, so…you do the math), what happens *afterward* is the real character metric of the sort of company with whom you’re dealing. The replacement process couldn’t have been more effortlessly simple, and as entirely prepared as I was to send back the damaged $50 item, that wasn’t something they even considered requesting of me. Generous, gracious, beyond fair, prompt, top-notch communicators—what more could you want? This is the way it’s done, folks. If only all sellers “got it” the way Theory11 gets it…but until that unlikely day dawns, I’ll just keep right on buying from them.

SCAMMED FOR $132 Ordered a special edition pack of lord of the rings cards and they never arrived. They should jave arrived 27th of December 2023, it is now 19th of February 2024. Multiple attempts to contact customer service have just gone ignored. I paid $132 for nothing. DON'T ORDER HERE. THIS WEBSTITE IS A SCAM. They will take your money and just never be heard from again.

Customer Support EXCELLENT I received my order incredibly quickly...unfortunately, the initial trick sent to me was not 100% made correctly....I reached out to Mandy and the support team and was incredibly, pleasantly surprised to not only get a quick response, but they shipped a replacement of the item that same day...one of the best customer support experiences I have had. Great Job Theory11!

BUYER BEWARE-TOTAL WASTE OF TIME & MONEY!! Nice cards, but ABSOLUTELY HORRIBLE CUSTOMER SERVICE! I ordered 3 decks of cards for a birthday gift 30 days before the event. 20 days go by & I contact Theory11 for help in getting the order in time-THEY COULD NOT CARE LESS! No Help-No Cards-NEVER received my order! They finally refunded my money after more than a month & made a snide comment about verifying my address when I re-order! WHAT A JOKE-Like that will ever happen! DON'T WASTE YOUR TIME OR MONEY WITH THIS COMPANY!!