50th Birthday Surprise - Online Order I recently ordered a gift/snack basket as a surprise for a friend's 50th birthday and my order was processed and delivered in less than 24 hours. I had admittedly procrastinated placing the order and Bake Me A Wish not only came through in a short time frame but they delivered it before noon the following day. My friend was thrilled with the goodies and the entire experience was incredibly easy and seamless. Thank you!

Difficult to get help when you do not receive your order I have used Bake Me A Wish for several years. Recently, I ordered a cake that was not delivered and does not show in my orders. I received a confirmation email and number for the order and the money was taken out of my account the day after I ordered. I have spent 2 hours trying to reach customer service by phone and email with no response. I expect better customer service when there is a problem. The cakes are delicious

Mushy inedible pie We ordered lemon meringue pie and with shipping cost over $80. When it defrosted it was complete mush and the meringue wilted. What a disappointment and useless for Thanksgiving. It was a gift for my father who is in long term care so truly sad. Update: the company refunded me completely. Well done! Updated from 1 to 3 stars

Don’t bother Very dry, tasteless and not worth the money. Go to a grocery store and you will get a fresher cake.

Terrible delivery- health hazard Delivered in the morning without notifying the receiver or calling to coordinate. This is good that needs to be refrigerated- it was sitting in the mail room until the evening (!), that we asked from the recipient to go check. Now it’s a cake that been out for 11 hours and now will have to go to the trash simply because the delivery guy did not call the recipient and inform them. It’s not a book, it food that can go bad!!