Bad disc Gamefly sent out a ps5 disc that was scratched all the way to hell and completely unreadable by my console. I lost a week waiting for the game just to get my time wasted further. Gamefly if you see this, your business model only works if you send out *working* games, please and thanks. For anyone considering Gamefly, please take this into account and think twice. Or maybe even thrice.

GameFly is dead GameFly is dead. They barely have any series X games. Dragon Quest XI is a popular one and they don’t have it. They barely have any Series X games. They used to have a huge library years ago. Seems like they are barely hanging on.

The site itself is good The site itself is good. Attempting to actually get a popular game when it comes out is VERY hard to do though. I typically wait until the game has been out a few months before I even think about getting it for rent from them. I've only gotten a couple of games that weren't readable. When I lost a game, they quickly sent the next game on my queue without question. Buying preowned games from them can be a REAL deal. with discounts and digital coupons they offer on occasion, I often times use them as gifts.

Won't Honor Orders Canceled my order because they suck at their jobs. They refused to honor the order saying they could cancel anything they liked. Edit: Response to GameFly - See "they suck at their jobs." I don't care about your bad information. You posted the item for that price and should 100% honor that price. But instead of honoring them, you canceled them like cowards and blame it on your supplier.

I feel scammed The games would take forever to arrive and sometimes wouldn't until I requested a replacement and then both copies showed on the same day and now I got charged for games currently in the mail to be returned. I sold my console because of it and now charged for games I don't have nor have a console for.