This "service" continues to degenerate This "service" continues to degenerate. Each time I've come back, I'm met with more frustration and disappointment. This time, within an entire months' membership, I only received 1 game. I only kept said game for 4 days, and sent it back, thinking it would be in time for other new releases. I watched my mailman pick up and scan the return envelope. It took an additional 4 days for Gamefly to receive the game, which in and of itself is a problem, considering they have a (broken) system in place that's supposed to recognize the moment a game is scanned and being sent back. Needless to say, because their system doesn't work. I was unable to get either of the games on my queue upon release. To add to to my frustration, I monitored said games and watched the availability raise from "low" to "normal" multiple times and still never received a game. I'm contemplating filling a report with the BBB. They're clearly unable to provide the "service" they're charging people for.

I don't really know why this site has… I don't really know why this site has such bad reviews but I'm guessing I've just had a different experience because this is my second time using gamefly and I think its great. Ive had no problems receiving games for the Nintendo switch and they even mailed my second game the day after I mailed back the first and they hadnt even received mine yet but they saw that I had sent it i guess and I received my second game before they evn had my first one back. Also the last time I used them before I moved I had sent back a game and it ended up lost in the mail somehow and they refunded me for a month of service. I really like this company, I thing their prices are reasonable, not great but eh.. also if you want to keep a game its often cheaper then you would get a used game anywhere else. I will be using them for a long time I think.

Horrible Service and Scam Business Horrible experience. They charged for me rentals that they never delivered even after double checking that I provided the correct shipping address and customer service is almost non-existent. I rented a game nearly one month ago and it was never delivered.

This company lacks reason and logic This company lacks reason and logic. I wasn't able to open an account because an older resident at my address never paid. This older resident owes 6 dollars. I offered to pay it and they wouldn't accept. This company literally turned down future business over 6 dollars 🤣🤣🤣.

Awful Company This company will steal your money. Awful customer service, awful website UI, if something goes wrong with a game they will not hesitate to charge your account without permission and make you jump through hoops to fix it. You can tell why it has such a low rating.